Friday, 20 November 2026

François Hollande: Beyond Political Ambition, a Question of Responsibility, Unity and Love for One's Country

 

When the future of a country becomes more important than the pursuit of power

There are political interviews that are quickly forgotten, and others that deserve closer attention because they reveal something deeper than the immediate political debate.

François Hollande's interview on LCI, on November 19, 2026, belongs to the second category.

Beyond the questions concerning Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, Raphaël Glucksmann and the 2027 presidential election, another subject gradually emerged: the future of France, the responsibility of political leaders and the increasingly fragile position of Europe in a rapidly changing international order.

What makes this interview particularly interesting is not simply what François Hollande said about the possibility of returning to the Élysée Palace. It is the way he approached that possibility.

He did not present the presidency as a personal ambition to be fulfilled at any cost. Instead, he repeatedly returned to the idea that France needs someone capable of bringing its people together, protecting its institutions and defending its interests in an increasingly uncertain world.

This distinction deserves attention.

A president must unite a country, not divide it

One of the strongest ideas emerging from Hollande's recent political interventions is the need to bring French society together.

France is experiencing political fragmentation, social tensions and a growing distance between citizens and political institutions. Political loyalties have become increasingly rigid, while public debate is often reduced to confrontation between opposing camps.

In this context, Hollande insists that the next president must be capable of representing something larger than a political party.

His message is particularly significant:

The next President of France must be someone who can unite the French people.

Not simply those who voted for him. Not merely the supporters of his political movement. But the country as a whole.

A presidential election should not become an exercise in determining which political camp can defeat another. It should be an opportunity to establish a common direction for the nation.

As Hollande stated during the LCI interview:

"Une élection présidentielle n'est pas une affaire de partis."

A presidential election is not simply a matter of political parties.

This is an important distinction, especially at a time when political divisions threaten to become permanent features of French public life.

The possible return of François Hollande: ambition or responsibility?

François Hollande has not officially declared his candidacy for the 2027 presidential election.

However, his statements leave the possibility open.

He has repeatedly suggested that his decision will depend on the political circumstances and, above all, on whether a genuine movement towards national unity becomes possible.

One of his most revealing statements was:

"Je ferai le choix qui me paraîtra le plus nécessaire pour mon pays, pas simplement pour ma famille politique."

"I will make the choice that I consider most necessary for my country, not simply for my political family."

These words deserve particular consideration.

They suggest that Hollande does not want to make a decision based exclusively on personal ambition or party interests.

He appears to be asking a different question: would his participation in the presidential election genuinely serve France?

That is a very different approach from simply announcing a candidacy because one wishes to return to power.

The coming months will be decisive. Hollande has indicated that the political situation must become clearer before he makes his decision. December 2026 and the beginning of 2027 are therefore important moments to watch.

If he eventually decides to run, it will be necessary to examine the reasons he gives for doing so, rather than assuming that his objective is simply to regain the presidency.

The international situation: Europe cannot afford to remain on the sidelines

Perhaps the most important dimension of Hollande's political thinking concerns the international situation.

On November 19, 2026, Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin met in Shenzhen, China, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit.

The meeting brought together the leaders of the three countries possessing the world's largest nuclear arsenals.

The discussions included nuclear arms control and strategic relations between the major powers.

TF1 Info+2

The symbolism of this meeting was considerable.

Three leaders, representing three major global powers, were sitting together to discuss issues capable of influencing the future of the international order.

Yet Europe was not represented at that trilateral meeting.

France and the United Kingdom, the two European countries possessing nuclear weapons, were not at the table.

This absence raises an important political question:

Can Europe continue to consider itself a major international power if decisions concerning global security are increasingly discussed without its participation?

France is not simply another European country. It is a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council, a nuclear-armed state and one of the principal military and diplomatic powers of the European continent.

The United Kingdom shares some of these strategic responsibilities.

Their absence from such a high-profile meeting should therefore encourage a serious discussion about Europe's diplomatic influence, its strategic independence and its capacity to defend its interests.

The concern is not merely about being present in a photograph.

It is about having a voice when decisions affecting the future of the world are being discussed.

China, Russia and the changing international financial order

Another important aspect of the international situation concerns the economic relationship between China, Russia and other emerging powers.

Both countries are members of BRICS, an international grouping that has been promoting greater economic cooperation and the use of national currencies in international trade.

The development of alternative payment mechanisms and the increased use of local currencies can gradually reduce dependence on the US dollar in certain transactions.

However, it would be inaccurate to claim that BRICS has officially established a common currency intended to replace the dollar. Its declared initiatives concern financial cooperation, payment systems and the increased use of national currencies.

brics.br+2

Nevertheless, the broader geopolitical significance is clear.

The international financial system is evolving, and the balance of economic influence is changing.

For France and Europe, understanding these developments is essential.

A country that does not anticipate international changes risks becoming dependent on decisions made elsewhere.

This is precisely why political leadership requires more than domestic popularity. It requires an understanding of the world and the ability to protect national interests within it.

Power is not an end in itself: protecting the country is the responsibility

There is another dimension to Hollande's statements that deserves particular attention.

The presidency should not be understood simply as the possession of power.

Power is a responsibility.

Its purpose should be to protect the country, defend its citizens, preserve its institutions and ensure that future generations inherit a stable and secure nation.

This is the interpretation that emerges from the broader message of his recent interventions.

A president should not seek the office merely because it is the highest political position in the country.

He should be prepared to assume its responsibilities because he believes he can contribute something necessary to the nation.

And this is where the question of François Hollande's possible candidacy becomes particularly interesting.

If he believes that France is facing a political and international situation requiring a different form of leadership, he may consider that remaining outside the presidential debate would itself be an irresponsible choice.

Whether this interpretation ultimately leads him to become a candidate remains to be seen.

But it is a question worth asking.

Beyond party politics: the human dimension of political responsibility

There is a tendency in modern politics to judge politicians exclusively through their electoral performance, their popularity or the mistakes made during their time in office.

François Hollande knows this particularly well.

His presidency was marked by considerable criticism, disappointment among sections of the electorate and the decision not to seek a second term in 2017.

His political record must, of course, remain open to scrutiny.

No former president should be exempt from criticism or historical assessment.

But political life should not necessarily be reduced to the permanent repetition of past judgments.

People can reflect, reconsider and change their understanding of what their country needs.

A former president may also acquire a different perspective after leaving office.

He no longer has the same institutional responsibilities, but he retains his experience, his knowledge of international affairs and his understanding of the difficulties involved in governing a country.

Perhaps this is one reason why Hollande's recent statements deserve to be examined beyond the usual political commentary.

He is presenting himself, at least in his own words, as someone who wants to consider the interests of France before those of his political family.

And, above all, as a French citizen who remains concerned about the future of his country.

If he decides to participate in the 2027 presidential election, he should be judged not only on his previous presidency, but also on the ideas, responsibilities and objectives he presents for the future.

A French citizen, a European and a human being before being a candidate

There is something important in the distinction between wanting power and accepting responsibility.

The former is an ambition.

The latter can be a commitment.

François Hollande's possible return to the presidential race raises precisely this question.

Would he be seeking to return to the Élysée Palace for personal reasons, or because he believes that the circumstances facing France and Europe require a political figure capable of bringing people together?

We cannot know his final decision or his private motivations.

But we can examine the principles he has chosen to emphasise publicly: unity, responsibility, national protection, European cooperation and the need to look beyond party interests.

If he eventually stands as a candidate, the most meaningful way to understand that decision may be to consider him first as a compatriot, not simply as a former president seeking another term.

A French citizen concerned about France.

A European aware that the continent's future cannot be separated from the international balance of power.

A politician who knows the responsibilities of the highest office.

And, before all these titles, a human being who must ultimately answer to his own conscience and to the history of his country.

The question history will eventually answer

The 2027 presidential election may become one of the most consequential moments in recent French political history.

France will have to decide what kind of leadership it wants, what place it intends to occupy in Europe and how it wishes to respond to a world in which major powers increasingly determine the international agenda.

The question is therefore not simply whether François Hollande will become a candidate.

The more important question is whether France can find a leader capable of uniting its citizens, protecting its sovereignty and defending its place in the world.

If Hollande believes that he can contribute to that objective, his decision to stand for election may be understood as more than a political comeback.

It may be presented as an acceptance of responsibility.

But the final judgment will belong to the French people.

History does not remember political leaders simply because they sought power. It remembers what they did with the responsibility entrusted to them.

SAISI

Thursday, 19 November 2026

CUBA: WHAT IS TRUE ABOUT THE “OPEN LETTER TO THE WORLD” CIRCULATING ON SOCIAL MEDIA?

                         
An open letter attributed to Cuban writer Ikay Romay accuses Washington of causing a humanitarian catastrophe on the island. We examine its origins and assess some of its most serious claims against available evidence.

An emotional open letter entitled “Open Letter to the World from the Island” has been circulating widely on social media. Attributed to Ikay Romay, it describes the suffering of ordinary Cubans and accuses the United States government of deliberately causing a humanitarian catastrophe through its economic sanctions against Cuba.

The text speaks of elderly people unable to obtain essential medicines, hospitals struggling to keep life-saving equipment running, newborn babies at risk because of electricity shortages, and food supplies being deliberately obstructed. It also praises Cuba's scientific achievements during the COVID-19 pandemic and calls the American embargo a crime against humanity.

Its emotional language and repeated calls to share the message have helped it circulate. But how much of it is supported by independently verifiable evidence?

Before examining the claims, it is important to establish where the letter comes from.

1. Where did the letter originate?

The earliest publication we could identify appeared on 13 February 2026, on the website Resumen Latinoamericano, under the title “Cuba. Carta abierta al mundo desde la Isla: una mujer de a pie denuncia el crimen que no quieren ver”, attributed to Ikay Romay.

An English translation was subsequently published by CounterPunch on 16 February 2026. The text was also reproduced by other publications, including People's World.

The original publication identifies the author as Ikay Romay. However, the appearance of a name and an attribution on a website does not, by itself, constitute independent verification of authorship. We have not found sufficient independent evidence to establish the circumstances in which the letter was written.

The distinction matters: the letter is a political and personal denunciation. It is not an investigative report accompanied by documents, statistics or independently verified case studies.

Sources: Resumen Latinoamericano — original publication · CounterPunch — English translation

2. Is the American embargo against Cuba real?

Yes. This is an established fact.

The United States has maintained a broad economic, commercial and financial embargo against Cuba for decades. Its restrictions affect trade, financial transactions, investment and the ability of Cuban entities to conduct business with certain international partners.

The measures can also create difficulties for foreign companies and financial institutions dealing with Cuba, including through the wider effects of American sanctions and restrictions.

The international opposition to the embargo has been repeatedly expressed at the United Nations General Assembly.

On 28 October 2026, the General Assembly adopted another resolution calling for the embargo to end. The vote was 130 in favour, 17 against and 25 abstentions.

The resolution is politically significant, but it is not legally binding on the United States.

It is therefore reasonable to say that the embargo contributes to Cuba's economic difficulties. However, it would be inaccurate to claim that every problem experienced by the country is caused exclusively by American policy.

Source: United Nations — Resolution A/RES/81/7

3. Are medicines and medical equipment difficult to obtain in Cuba?

Yes. Shortages are documented, although their causes are complex.

Cuba has experienced serious shortages of medicines, medical supplies, spare parts and equipment. The country's healthcare system has also been affected by the economic crisis, inflation, the departure of healthcare professionals and difficulties maintaining infrastructure.

American sanctions can make international purchases, payments and commercial relationships more difficult. Even when humanitarian goods are permitted, the practical process of obtaining them can be complicated by financial and logistical restrictions.

However, it is important to distinguish between the existence of shortages and the precise cause of each shortage.

The available evidence does not allow us to attribute every missing medicine or piece of equipment to the American embargo alone.

The Pan American Health Organization (PAHO), part of the World Health Organization system, has documented shortages of medicines, laboratory supplies and basic materials needed to maintain health services in Cuba.

Source: PAHO/WHO — Crisis Situation in Cuba

4. Are newborn babies and hospital patients at risk because of power cuts?

Yes. The risks to patients are real and have been documented.

Cuba's energy crisis has placed enormous pressure on hospitals and other essential services.

Electricity is indispensable for intensive care units, operating theatres, incubators, ventilators, laboratories and the refrigeration systems used to store vaccines, blood products and temperature-sensitive medicines.

In May 2026, the United Nations reported that hospitals were suspending operations and struggling to keep life-saving equipment running amid severe shortages of electricity, fuel and medical supplies.

The UN also warned that newborn babies dependent on incubators or ventilators were particularly vulnerable when electricity supplies failed.

This supports the central concern expressed in the letter: power cuts can have serious consequences for human lives.

Nevertheless, a general warning about the risks to hospital patients is not proof of every specific incident described in a social media message. Each alleged case of an incubator being switched off, for example, would need to be verified separately.

Sources: United Nations — Cuba is Running Out of Time. We Need Fuel Now to Save Lives · The BMJ — Cuba: Hospitals on brink as oil runs out

5. Is the suffering of elderly people caused directly by the embargo?

Medicine shortages are real, but the specific allegations in the letter are not independently demonstrated.

Older people and patients with chronic conditions are particularly vulnerable when essential medicines become difficult to obtain.

People suffering from heart disease, diabetes and high blood pressure may depend on regular treatment. Interruptions in access to medicines can have serious consequences.

The embargo can contribute to these difficulties by complicating imports and financial transactions.

However, the letter does not provide medical records, documented cases or independent statistics proving that particular elderly people died specifically because of medicines blocked by the United States.

It is important not to confuse a serious and credible public-health problem with proof of a particular cause of death.

6. Is Cuba facing a deliberate policy of starvation imposed by Washington?

The food crisis is real. The claim of a deliberate policy to cause famine is not established by the evidence presented.

Cuba depends heavily on imported food and is facing a combination of economic difficulties, inflation, shortages of fuel, reduced purchasing power and problems with domestic production and distribution.

American restrictions can make international trade more difficult and contribute to the country's economic pressure.

But the expression “programmed famine” goes much further. It suggests a deliberate intention to starve the population.

The letter does not provide evidence sufficient to establish such an intention.

The causes of food insecurity in Cuba are complex and include external restrictions as well as internal economic and structural problems.

A serious discussion of the country's food crisis must take all these factors into account.

7. Has Cuba developed its own COVID-19 vaccines?

Yes. This is one of the claims in the letter that is supported by scientific and institutional sources.

Cuba developed five COVID-19 vaccine candidates:

  • Soberana 01
  • Soberana 02
  • Soberana Plus
  • Abdala
  • Mambisa

Three of these — Abdala, Soberana 02 and Soberana Plus — received emergency-use authorisation in Cuba.

This was a significant scientific achievement, particularly for a country with limited resources and substantial economic constraints.

The Pan American Health Organization documented the development of these vaccine candidates.

However, the statement that Cuba accomplished this entirely without outside assistance is too absolute. Scientific research takes place within international networks of knowledge, cooperation and exchange.

The achievement itself is genuine; the suggestion that it happened in complete isolation is not established.

Source: PAHO — Science, Technology and Innovation for Health in Cuba

8. Are ships carrying food and medicine being deliberately prevented from reaching Cuba?

The difficulties affecting trade and transport are documented, but the letter does not identify specific ships or incidents.

American sanctions and their wider financial consequences can discourage companies, banks and shipping operators from doing business involving Cuba.

These restrictions can create additional costs, delays and uncertainty for international transactions.

Nevertheless, the letter does not name particular ships, shipping companies, dates or documented cases in which food shipments were deliberately intercepted or prevented from reaching the island.

There is also an important distinction between the existence of restrictions and a complete prohibition on humanitarian trade.

The US Treasury Department, for example, states that its sanctions are not intended to target non-US persons involved in providing food, medicines or medical devices to Cuba under the conditions it describes.

This does not mean that the practical difficulties disappear. It does mean that the legal situation is more complicated than the claim that all such supplies are simply prohibited.

Source: US Treasury — Office of Foreign Assets Control, FAQ 1264

9. Is the American embargo legally a crime against humanity?

That is a political and legal accusation, not an established judicial finding.

The expression “crime against humanity” has a precise meaning under international criminal law.

Article 7 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court defines crimes against humanity through specific acts committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack directed against a civilian population, with knowledge of that attack.

The letter uses the expression to condemn the humanitarian consequences of American policy.

That is a political position which can be debated. However, the existence of sanctions and their harmful consequences does not, by itself, establish that the legal criteria for a crime against humanity have been met.

No conclusion of that kind should be presented as an established judicial fact without the relevant legal determination.

Source: International Criminal Court — Rome Statute, Article 7

10. Is Washington solely responsible for Cuba's current crisis?

No. The situation cannot be explained by one factor alone.

The American embargo has had a significant impact on Cuba's economy and its international relations. Its consequences should not be minimised.

At the same time, Cuba has faced long-standing structural economic problems, insufficient investment, deteriorating infrastructure, difficulties in domestic production, inflation and the emigration of a considerable number of professionals.

These internal factors have also contributed to the deterioration of public services and living conditions.

A balanced assessment must therefore consider both external pressure and internal responsibility.

Recognising the impact of American sanctions does not require ignoring the decisions and policies of the Cuban authorities. Equally, recognising internal problems does not justify disregarding the effects of the embargo.

CONCLUSION: BETWEEN REAL SUFFERING AND POLITICAL RHETORIC

The open letter attributed to Ikay Romay raises issues that deserve serious attention.

Cuba is experiencing a profound economic and humanitarian crisis. Shortages of medicines, fuel and food, prolonged power cuts and pressure on hospitals are not imaginary problems. They have been documented by international organisations, including the United Nations and the Pan American Health Organization.

The American embargo is also real and has contributed to the country's economic difficulties. Its effects on trade, finance and access to resources should not be dismissed.

However, the letter combines documented facts with emotional language, political interpretations and allegations that are not always supported by independent evidence.

Some claims are broadly confirmed. Others require further verification. And some, particularly those concerning deliberate starvation or specific deaths directly caused by the embargo, are not demonstrated by the information provided.

The central question is not whether the Cuban people are suffering. They are.

The question is whether we can understand that suffering without reducing a complex reality to a single explanation.

Informing the public means recognising human suffering, questioning political claims and checking the evidence — regardless of which government or political movement is being criticised.

Sharing a message is easy. Verifying it is our responsibility.

SAISI NEWS — Inform, Question, Verify.


Wednesday, 18 November 2026

France’s Student Protests: How a School Crisis Turned into a Nationwide Social Movement

 

From teachers and classrooms to riots, arrests and wider demands — what is really happening in France?


A movement that began in a high school

France has been experiencing one of its most significant youth protest movements in years.

The movement began in September 2026, initially around very concrete problems inside French public high schools. The first major mobilisation emerged at the Saint-Exupéry High School in Créteil, near Paris, where several teaching positions were unfilled. Students complained about missing teachers and staff, overcrowded classes, deteriorating school buildings and the pressure associated with Parcoursup, France's university admissions system.

What started as local school blockades quickly spread through the Paris region and then to other parts of France. By September 28, the French Interior Ministry said that around 180 schools were affected. Student organisations called for wider mobilisation, arguing that the problems they were experiencing were not limited to one particular school.

The demands were initially largely educational:

  • more teachers and school staff;
  • replacement of absent teachers;
  • better-maintained school buildings;
  • less overcrowding;
  • improved working and studying conditions;
  • changes concerning Parcoursup;
  • and, depending on the school, more specific demands such as changes to school rules or canteen conditions.

In other words, the movement did not begin as a riot. It began as a protest about education.


From school blockades to a much broader protest

During October, however, the mobilisation changed considerably.

The education issue became increasingly connected to wider dissatisfaction over the cost of living, wages, public services and the political direction of the country.

On October 17, the demonstrations reached a particularly violent turning point. Reuters reported that more than half a million people took part in demonstrations across France, while looting and destruction affected thousands of businesses and public buildings were attacked. Police faced major confrontations in cities including Paris, Marseille and Lyon.

This is where an important distinction must be made.

Not everyone taking part in the demonstrations was involved in violence.

The French Interior Ministry itself reported that many officially organised demonstrations proceeded peacefully. At the same time, authorities reported groups attacking police, damaging property, setting fires and using fireworks or improvised projectiles.

The government has attributed much of the violence to radical and far-left groups and opportunistic looters. However, Reuters noted that police and intelligence sources have also cautioned that evidence of a centrally organised role for such groups remains uncertain.

That distinction is essential if one wants to understand the movement rather than simply describe it as a "student riot."


How long has the protest lasted?

If we take September 21 as the beginning of the movement, then by November 18 the protests have lasted almost two months — approximately eight weeks.

Although the scale of the mobilisation has decreased in some places, the situation has not completely returned to normal.

On November 13, Le Monde reported that around 200 of France's approximately 3,700 high schools had experienced disruption during the previous 15 days. Around 80 had been repeatedly blocked and about 50 almost systematically. More than 100 schools had also moved some teaching online because of security concerns.

So the movement is no longer at the same national intensity as during its peak, but it has not simply disappeared.


Injuries: students, teachers and police

The human cost has become one of the most controversial aspects of the crisis.

According to figures reported by Le Monde on November 13, authorities counted approximately:

360 students injured

and

240 members of education staff injured.

Police and gendarmes have also suffered injuries.

For example, during the national mobilisation of November 5, the Interior Ministry reported 53 members of the security forces injured. It also recorded 86 fire-service interventions and 448 arrests or detentions by 6 p.m. that day.

These figures should nevertheless be read carefully. The numbers concern different categories and different periods, so they should not simply be added together to produce a single casualty figure for the entire movement.

There has also been intense controversy over the conduct of the police.

Human-rights organisations, lawyers and some protesters have accused the authorities of excessive use of force, while the government maintains that police have been responding to increasingly violent attacks and protecting schools, public buildings and demonstrators.

Reuters reported that authorities had opened 161 investigations into alleged police violence.


Fires, destruction and looting

The protests have also resulted in serious damage.

According to the Interior Ministry, incidents have included:

  • fires at school entrances;
  • damaged school buildings;
  • destroyed classrooms and equipment;
  • fireworks and mortar attacks;
  • stones and other projectiles thrown at police;
  • attacks on firefighters;
  • and improvised explosive devices discovered in school buildings.

One particularly serious incident occurred in Toulouse, where mortar fire caused a fire that completely destroyed a 100-square-metre school-life facility, while other rooms and computers were damaged. Firefighters responding to the incident were themselves attacked with projectiles.

In Lille, a high-school entrance gate was set on fire, leading to an evacuation because of the risk of a gas leak. In Caen, two high schools suffered significant damage, while authorities in Mennecy reported mortar fire inside a school and the discovery of a homemade explosive device.

Beyond schools, the October 17 riots also produced widespread damage to businesses.

Reuters reported that thousands of businesses were affected by looting and destruction, while public buildings were attacked in several major cities.


Arrests: a number that needs explanation

One of the most striking features of the crisis has been the enormous number of arrests and police detentions.

But here again, it is important not to confuse different legal categories.

An arrest or police detention does not mean that the person was convicted of a crime.

On October 9, the Justice Ministry reported that 6,877 people had been placed in police custody since the beginning of the violence. Of those, 5,890 were minors and 987 were adults. At that point, 2,376 people were facing prosecution.

A later Justice Ministry study examined 1,504 minors who had actually been brought before judicial authorities. The study found that they were mostly boys, with an average age of 16, and that the majority had no previous criminal record. The offences generally involved violence against public officials, property damage or possession of objects used as weapons.

This is an important detail: many of the young people arrested were ordinary students with no previous criminal record.


And what about prison sentences?

The latest figures available today provide a clearer picture of the judicial consequences.

On November 18, Justice Minister Gérald Darmanin said that 7,184 people had been placed in police custody in connection with the demonstrations against the cost of living since October 17.

Those cases had resulted in:

  • 3,053 prosecutions
  • 2,301 people brought before a judge
  • 466 prison sentences
  • including 195 unconditional prison sentences
  • and 111 cases involving immediate detention orders.

The minister also said that 356 people were deprived of their liberty as of November 16, including people serving prison sentences and people held in pre-trial detention.

These figures mainly concern the broader cost-of-living and social protests since October 17, rather than every person who participated in the original school demonstrations.

That distinction is crucial.


What do the students actually want?

At the heart of the movement remains a relatively simple question:

What kind of education system does France want to provide to its young people?

The original student demands focused on teachers, staffing, classrooms, school buildings and the pressure surrounding university admissions.

But the movement has now become much broader.

Many young protesters have also expressed concerns about:

  • purchasing power;
  • the cost of living;
  • public services;
  • social inequality;
  • employment prospects;
  • and France's political future.

The government has announced measures concerning education and proposed bringing forward a minimum-wage increase, but student organisations and unions have argued that these measures do not go far enough. Reuters reported that further demonstrations were still being planned.


A protest movement with two very different faces

Perhaps the most accurate way to describe what has happened in France is to recognise that two realities have existed at the same time.

On one side are thousands of students, teachers, parents and workers demanding better schools, better public services and better living conditions.

On the other side, there have been episodes of serious violence: fires, looting, attacks on police and teachers, damaged schools and businesses, and the use of fireworks, mortars and improvised weapons.

Neither reality cancels out the other.

A peaceful student asking for a teacher should not automatically be described as a rioter.

At the same time, a person who burns a school, attacks a firefighter or throws a projectile at a police officer cannot simply be excused because the action takes place during a legitimate demonstration.

The right to protest and the responsibility not to commit violence must coexist.


What happens next?

As France moves towards the 2027 presidential election, the protests have acquired a significance that goes beyond the classroom.

On November 17, demonstrations involving public-sector unions, private-sector workers and young people continued across France. The Interior Ministry estimated 146,000 participants, while the CGT union claimed more than 500,000. The demonstrations were largely peaceful, but participants continued to raise concerns about wages, purchasing power and declining public services.

The French government therefore faces a difficult challenge: restoring order and protecting people and property while also addressing the grievances that brought so many people onto the streets in the first place.

The original question was about schools.

Today, the question is much larger:

What kind of France do young people believe they will inherit — and what kind of France do they want to build?


A Recent Development: What the Numbers Tell Us

In November 2026, the French Ministry of Justice published a study examining the profiles of 1,504 minors brought before the judicial authorities in connection with the recent high-school student protests, between 22 September and 9 October 2026.

One finding deserves particular attention: 83% of these young people had no previous judicial record, and almost nine out of ten were attending school at the time of the events.

The findings offer a more nuanced picture of the young people involved. Behind the headlines about arrests and clashes, there are also ordinary teenagers, many experiencing their first encounter with the justice system.

It is important to remember that these figures concern minors referred to the judicial authorities, not the entire student protest movement. Nevertheless, they remind us that student demonstrations cannot be understood simply through images of confrontation and disorder.

Behind every statistic, there is a young person, a personal story and a future still being shaped.


SAISI NEWS — Editorial note

The figures in this article come from French government institutions, judicial authorities and independent reporting. Numbers concerning demonstrations, arrests and injuries can vary according to the date, methodology and definition used. In particular, an “arrest” or “police detention” should not be interpreted as a conviction.

SAISI